Friday, May 20, 2016

Whovian Chatter: The Tom Baker Years Seasons Fourteen and Fifteen

Ghost here, thanks for joining.

I'm going to be examining Doctor Who... every single episode.  I'm going to take you on a journey through the 50+ years worth of this show, showcasing the good and the bad along the way.  For each episode I'm going to give you a very brief rundown of the plot, how good/bad the story is, and anything interesting about the episode.  Basically I'll just talk about whatever comes to mind for each of them.  These will be a more in-depth overview of the series as a whole so you can see which stories or episodes (if any) you want to check out for yourself.  Today I'm going to be talking about

The Fourth Doctor
Tom Baker
Seasons Fourteen and Fifteen

Season Fourteen ran from September 4, 1976 to April 2, 1977.  It contained twenty six episodes across six stories.  The Golden Era of Classic Doctor Who continued despite the mid-season departure of the Doctor's best friend, Sarah Jane.  It was during this season that Tom Baker really started into his alcohol fueled pride and difficulty to work with.  He was convinced that the Doctor didn't need a companion and so the show runners gave him one story without a companion.  When this was deemed a failure as the Doctor needed someone to talk to, Tom Baker said that the next companion should be a talking cabbage; he wasn't joking either.  Fortunately we ended up getting Leela, a savage warrior from the future!  They start a sort of Eliza Doolittle and Professor Higgins relationship that really worked well and continued making the show great into the next season.  This season also has a TARDIS console room that is all wooden.  Sadly it only lasts for this season because storage in between this and next season warped the panels but this is a good look for the TARDIS.

Season Fifteen ran from September 3, 1977 to March 11, 1978.  It contained twenty six episodes across six stories.  Season Fifteen saw the departure of Philip Hinchcliffe as the producer and Graham Williams taking over.  Robert Holmes was also replaced as script editor mid-season.  As per usual when a new producer was taking over the show, the stamp of the old producer was still on for the first few stories, and you can the subtle shift here.  Although the show still had Tom Baker as the Doctor and Leela as the companion, you could definitely see a slip in quality towards the end of the season.  It's not that the Williams era was bad, it just fewer and fewer truly great stories.  The show just couldn't keep up with the quality of the previous three seasons partially due to budgetary constraints but we'll get to that in a later segment.

Season Fourteen


Story 86
The Masque of Mandragora

The first story of season fourteen is The Masque of Mandragora and it's four episodes long.  The Doctor is showing Sarah Jane around the TARDIS and finds the secondary console room.  While there they see a living energy within the Time Vortex known as the Mandragora Helix.  The Helix attacks the TARDIS and a portion of it hops on board unknown to the Doctor.  The TARDIS then lands in 15th century Italy where Sarah Jane is kidnapped by the Brotherhood of Demnos to be used as a sacrifice.  The Doctor attempts to save her but is stopped by the royal guards and witnesses the Helix kill a guard.  The Doctor attempts to convince the nobles of the danger the Helix can bring but it falls on deaf ears.  Eventually the Doctor escapes and frees Sarah Jane as the Helix approaches the Brotherhood and offers them power in exchange for their servitude.  The Doctor fears that the Mandragora Helix could rule Earth under a new religion as this was the time period between the Dark Ages and Rennaisance.  The Doctor, Sarah Jane, and a noble named Gulianno attempt to stop the Brotherhood before they gain power.

This is a fairly decent story with some interesting ideas.  I didn't mention it in the plot portion, but the leader of the Brotherhood is a seer for the Duke whose been working with another man to make his predictions come true; namely that anyone who is predicted to die will be poisoned that day.  It's also interesting to see the main problem of the story being accidentally caused by the Doctor.  It's a pretty standard episode.  Check it out if it sounds interesting to you.


Story 87
The Hand of Fear

The next story is The Hand of Fear and it's four episodes long.  This is Sarah Jane's last story as a full companion.  When the Doctor and Sarah Jane land the TARDIS in a quarry that's about to explode, the avalanche uncovers a stone hand that the unconscious Sarah Jane can't let go of.  The hand possesses Sarah and causes her to enter a nuclear facility so that the hand can absorb the radiation and be reborn.  The hand is an alien named Eldrad who's ship crashed on earth millennia ago.  Edrad convinces the Doctor to take her back to her home planet.  However upon reaching the planet they find it barren and full of booby traps.  Eldrad is seemingly destroyed by one of the traps but he emerges later in his true masculine form being fully regenerated.  However, the Doctor and Eldrad discover a prerecorded message from Eldrad's people.  It turns out that Eldrad was an evil tyrant who was sent away from the planet.  His race all accepted extinction and destroyed their race banks in case Eldrad were to ever return.  Eldrad decides to make a new empire on Earth but the Doctor trips him into a bottomless abyss.  The Doctor and Sarah Jane re-enter the TARDIS when the Doctor receives a summons to Gallifrey and he cannot take Sarah.  The Doctor leaves Sarah Jane on earth and ventures to Gallifrey.

This is a bit of a weird one, but still very good.  It's not that often that we see an alien creature just looking to revive itself and get back home.  True, the alien still turned out to be a villain, but for the majority of this story we don't know that.  It was also interesting to see Eldrad's first form being female because of the imprinting of Sarah Jane.  It's too bad his normal form isn't exactly that exciting; then again how inventive can you really get with rock creatures?  Also notable is Sarah Jane's outfit which Elisabeth Sladen cursed until the day of her death.  This was Sarah Jane's last normal adventure with the Doctor.  Luckily we will see her once more in the classic series and a few more times in the new series as well!

Story 88
The Deadly Assassin

The next story is The Deadly Assassin and it's four episodes long.  The Doctor returns to Gallifrey because of a strange summons where he foresees the President of Gallifrey being assassinated.  The President plans to retire and Chancellor Goth is expected to take the nomination.  He goes undercover and attempts to stop the assassin but is captured and blamed for the President's death.  While under interrogation, the Doctor tells that he has been framed, and in order to prolong his sentencing to find evidence, the Doctor puts in his name for the ballot of President.  Due to Gallifreyan law, he cannot be executed during this time, so the Doctor goes about looking for clues.  Eventually, he discovers a time lord guard having been shrunken in size; the calling card of The Master.  Since we last saw him, the Master has had a failed regeneration and he is basically a walking rotting corpse now.  The Doctor realizes that it was the Master who sent him the vision from inside the Matrix (an electronic neural network...basically JUST like the Keanu Reeves movie.)  The Doctor goes in to the Matrix to stop the master and finds that the assassin is actually Chancellor Goth working with the Master.  The Master tries to overload the Matrix but a friendly time lord helps the Doctor out; Goth is not so lucky.  The Master's plan is to obtain all of the presidential items in order to open up the Eye of Harmony and destroy Gallifrey along with countless other planets.  The Doctor stops the Master, but the Master escapes in his TARDIS.

This one is a unique story in Doctor Who and it's considered one of the greatest stories of the classic show.  It's basically a giant re-telling of The Manchurian Candidate...which is honestly fine with me.  This story brought us back The Master after many years of his absence.  It was great to see the character again although it wasn't pleasing to look on his actual face.  This story also introduced the Matrix which will be instrumental in a later Colin Baker season and be mentioned a few times in the new show.  This is the only classic Doctor Who story which doesn't feature a companion.  Since the majority of the segments taking place in the Matrix have almost no dialogue, this experimental story was considered a failure at the time.  It was generally not received very well, yet now it's considered one of the absolute best.  Definitely check this one out!

Story 89
The Face of Evil

The next story is The Face of Evil and it's four episodes long.  The Doctor, now on his own, lands the TARDIS on a jungle planet where he meets a Sevateem warrior named Leela; she was exiled from her people for profaning against their god Xoanon.  She claims the Doctor to be "The Evil One" who is holding their god captive.  The Doctor is taken to her people and he realizes that their god is speaking to them through Earth technology.  Eventually the Doctor sees his own face on the side of a mountain but has no idea why.  The Doctor and Leela find their way to the Tesh (another group of people worshiping Xoanon) and finally the Doctor remembers.  The Sevateem and Tesh are descendants of an Earth Colony where a computer was malfunctioning.  The Survey Team and the Technicians were separated when the Doctor repaired the machine but forgot to remove his personality imprint from the computer; this gave the computer a split personality.  It's up to the Doctor to fully repair the machine once more before Xoanon uses it's mind control on the people to kill each other.

This is a weird one and honestly the weakest of the season.  One interesting and weird thing about this is the fact that this is the Doctor correcting a previous mistake that we never actually got to see him perform.  It's also creepy to see the computer displaying Tom Baker's voice shouting "Who Am I?" but a small child's voice coming out.  The only real important thing about this story is Leela's arrival on the TARDIS.  Leela is definitely a savage warrior and doesn't have time for many of the niceties of society.  She'll cut your throat as soon as look at you if necessary.  She and the Doctor have an excellent dynamic.  If you want to see Leela's first story then check it out, if not then feel free to skip this one.


Story 90
The Robots of Death

The next story is The Robots of Death and it's four episodes long.  The TARDIS lands on a sand mining ship in the future and within seconds a man is killed.  The Doctor and Leela are suspected to be the murderers and are locked away.  However when another murder happens, a man named Poul and a robot named D84 believe their story and free them to investigate the multiple murders.  Poul and D84 are undercover agents from the mining company to investigate rumors of a robot revolution being instigated by a man named Taren Capel who was raised by robots.  The Doctor eventually finds evidence that Capel is on board and modifying the existing robot's programming to kill humans.  It's up to the four of them to stop Capel's scheme at any cost.

This story is decent at best.  It's got some neat ideas going on with D84 being self-controlled and eventually sacrificing his life for the better of the human crew.  Past that, there's not really a whole lot to praise or criticize it's just a decent story.  Although, for the story to be called "Robots of Death" I think it took just a bit too long for everyone to figure out what was going on.  If you think "I, Robot" done in the 70's sounds good then check it out.

Story 91
The Talons of Weng-Chiang

The last story of the season is The Talons of Weng-Chiang and it's six episodes long.  Leela wishes to study the customs of her ancestors, so the Doctor takes her to Victorian London to see Li H'sen Chang at the theatre.  While there, they witness a group of Chinese men who have murdered another man.  A nearby policeman scares most off but one Chinese man, the Doctor, and Leela are taken in for questioning about the body.  Chang is summoned to act as interpreter but he is actually the group's leader and slips the man a capsule which causes the man to die immediately.  The Doctor meets with Professor Litefoot who is performing the autopsies notices that the first man is husband to a woman who has gone missing in the lastest spree of missing women.  The Doctor, however, notices a mark on the Chinese man as the mark of the Tong of the Black Scorpion; a group who worship the ancient god Weng-Chiang.  Chang, as it turns out, is working for Magnus Greel, a villain from the 51st century who used a time cabinet to escape his own destruction and has been masquerading as the god Weng-Chaing.  Due to the time cabinet messing with his DNA, Greel must use the life force of women to remain alive.  Eventually the Doctor finds Greel's lair and with the help of Leela, Professor Litefoot and a man named Jago, they attempt to stop Greel once and for all.

This is another absolute classic.  There were a lot of points that I couldn't really talk about in the plot unless I wanted to speak forever about it.  My favorite part of this whole story is when Litefoot and Leela are eating dinner together.  He has all kinds of foods so Leela being Leela just picks up the meat and eats with her hands.  Litefoot trying not to embarrass his guest does the same.  Comedy of manners at it's finest!  It was also neat to see Deep Roy (the man who was all of the oompa loompas Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory) playing a role in this story as the evil Mr. Sin.  There's much more comedy and excitement than I could even begin to describe here.  You definitely need to check this one out!

Season Fifteen

Story 92
Horror of Fang Rock

The first story of season fifteen is Horror of Fang Rock and it's four episodes long.  The TARDIS lands in Edwardian England on the island of Fang Rock where they notice the lighthouse isn't functioning.  The Doctor and Leela investigate only to find a dead body and that the electrics have been going in and out.  The two workers still alive mention that a shining light has landed in the ocean nearby.  Due to the power failure, a ship crashed onto the island and the four survivors are brought on board.  Unfortunately more and more people are being murdered by a green glowing alien and one of the lighthouse crew, Reuben has reacted poorly to the shock.  More people keep dying as the Doctor discovers Reuben's body; the alien can transform its shape.  It turns out that the alien is a Rutan, a green blob whose race is the enemy of the Sontarans.  They are losing the war against the Sontarans and plan on using Earth as a new base and eliminating humans from it.  The Doctor and Leela stop the Rutan but only after it has murdered every other person on the island.  As the Rutan mothership approaches, the Doctor rigs the lighthouse with diamonds to create a heated laser and destroy the ship.

This is a very bleak and very good story.  Doctor Who in general has a higher death count than many television shows, but it's not very often that every single character other than the Doctor and his companion die.  The mystery and atmosphere of this story is fantastic.  Originally this was just supposed to be some random alien, but writer Terrance Dicks remembered Pertwee's The Time Warrior and decided to make the villain a Rutan.  This is the only time we've seen a Rutan and I really wish they would come back to the new show.  Check this story out!


Story 93
The Invisible Enemy

The next story is The Invisible Enemy and it's four episodes long.  Humans have been colonizing space at a rapid pace and several of them have come into contact with a virus that takes over their bodies and are using Titan Base as a breeding ground for the virus.  The station manager sends out an SOS which the Doctor picks up.  Unfortunately the Doctor also contracts the virus and is chosen to house the nucleus of the storm due to his abilities as a Time Lord.  Without any options left, The TARDIS heads to a hospital with the Doctor, Leela, and unknown to them, an infected man.  The infected man begins spreading the virus to the hospital staff as Professor Marius examines the Doctor.  The only course of action is to create clones of the Doctor and Leela (which can only live for 10 minutes) and shrink them down to travel through the Doctor's brain and destroy the nucleus.  While they do this, the real Leela and Marius' robot dog, K-9 defend the room from the infected.  Unfortunately the Nucleus is intelligent and uses the plan against them and escapes the Doctor's mind to be enlarged by reversing the shrink ray.  The Doctor, now clean of the infection and knowing a cure for it, follows the Nucleus and the infected to Titan Base to stop them for good.

This one is very different.  It ultimately becomes The Fantastic Voyage done to 70's Doctor Who...something they would later revisit with the Twelfth Doctor story Into the Dalek.  Basically if you've seen any show or movie about shrinking people down inside a body then you've seen this.  The most important thing to come from this story is the introduction of K-9 who joins the TARDIS at the end.  He's the companion that a lot of people either really enjoy or really hate.  Sometimes he's used very well but other times he's a bit annoying.


Story 94
Image of the Fendahl

The next story is Image of the Fendahl and it's four episodes long.  Four scientists have discovered an ancient skull and are running scans on it.  These scans activate the skull and cause a creature to briefly appear and completely suck the life force out of anything nearby.  The time scanning tech catches the eye of the Doctor who investigates.  Eventually the skull has chosen the female scientist to become the new host of the Fendahleen and commands her to set the scanner to be permanently on.  The possessed scientist then begins sucking the life force out of some and converting others into large worm-like creatures.  If the Fendahl gains twelve followers it can summon an insurmountable amount of power and destroy the planet.  The Doctor discovers the Fendahleen are fatally allergic to salt and kill two of the twelve causing the circle to be unfinished.  The Doctor rigs the scanning machine to explode and cause the skull to go dormant once again.  The explosion caused a chain reaction which destroyed all of the transformed Fendahleen and the Doctor leaves to toss the skull into a supernova.

This one is... just OK.  I said in the introduction that this season started a bit of a minor slip in quality and this is the story that I first really noticed it in.  I'm not sure if it was the script or just the general idea but the majority of this story left me just sort of watching but not absorbing much of what was going on.  It just sort of exists.  There are a few good scenes here and there but mostly this one is forgettable.

Story 95
The Sun Makers

The next story is The Sun Makers and it's four episodes long.  With the Earth being uninhabited (think around the time of the Ark in Space) there is a large colony living on Pluto who are being taxed beyond their ability.  When the TARDIS lands on Pluto, the Doctor and Leela stop a man from committing suicide because of the taxation.  Listening to his story, the Doctor decides to investigate "The Company" as he seeks out people who are living underground who oppose the Company and it's leader, the Collector.  It turns out that the Collector is actually a strange seaweed-like alien in human form.  Eventually with the help of the underground movement starting a rebellion, the Doctor sabotages the Company to go bankrupt and traps the Collector inside his life support system.  With Pluto free from The Company, the Doctor and Leela head back to the TARDIS.

This one is a bit of an oddity for much of Doctor Who.  While many of Classic Doctor Who stories involve planetary destruction, invasion, or protecting a nation, this one is just the Doctor having compassion because the living conditions are terrible.  That's something you don't see too incredibly often with this show.  Though I don't talk about writers too often, this is yet another good script by Robert Holmes.  Holmes was one of the best writers for the show.  Even things that aren't exactly exciting like this one are written so well that you end up liking it anyway.  Holmes tended to write about things that were pissing him off at the time and apparently this time it was paying taxes.  I wouldn't say this is an absolute classic episode but I enjoyed it.  Check it out if it seems interesting to you.


Story 96
Underworld

The next story is Underworld and it's four episodes long.  The Time Lords started their policy of non-interference because of their involvement with the Minyans of the planet Minyos.  The Minyans worshiped them as gods but eventually used the advanced technology and weaponry against the Time Lords and blew up the planet.  Two ships escaped the destruction.  One of them had the race bank of the Minyans and the other was trying to find the race bank and return everyone to the new Minyos II.  Several millenia have passed since then and the Doctor, Leela, and K-9 land on the second ship which is closing in on the first.  They find that the first ship had attracted rocks and became a planet.  Inside, the descendants of the original crew are working as slaves under the two robot Seers and the super computer the Oracle.  Eventually the slaves are freed and the race bank is rescued so that the Minyans can return to Minyos II.

This may sound interesting but... it's not.  There are some really good ideas with this plotline but for some reason it falls completely flat.  This is another one that I had to look up what it was even about.  Why?  Well to be perfectly honest, I've tried to watch this story three times and all three times I've fallen asleep.  It's not like it was late night or I had been watching a ton of them in the same day either; it was just so slow that it put me to sleep.  Give this one a pass.


Story 97
The Invasion of Time

The last story of Season Fifteen is The Invasion of Time and it's six episodes long.  The Doctor returns again on Gallifrey to claim the office of President as the last election was only between himself and the now deceased Chancellor Goth.  The Time Lords are outraged but can't really do anything about it.  The Doctor is acting very strangely though and begins making demands that his chamber be completely lead lined and is just generally being demanding and rude.  The Doctor is after all of the artifacts of Rassilon which would give him ultimate power within the Time Lords.  The Time Lords remind him that outsiders are not permitted in Gallifrey and so he banishes Leela to the outskirts.  It seems that the Doctor is working with an alien race known as the Vardans and assisting them with invading Gallifrey.  The Doctor takes Time Lord Borusa to his chamber, which is now lead lined and will prevent mind reading, and explains that he is working with the Vardans so that they will fully manifest their physical form.  Once the Vardans show who they really are he can trap their planet in a time loop and save Gallifrey.  Leela meets with some other outsiders and they form a resistance group to get back into Gallifrey to help the Doctor with whatever is going on.  Eventually the Doctor lowers Gallifrey's sheilds to allow the Vardans in and identifies them.  The Doctor sends the Vardans back and traps their planet in an infinite time loop.  Unfortunately, this seems to have been a ploy by the Sontarans to gain access to Gallifrey as they beam in immediately after.  Using the lost Key of Rassilon, the Doctor and a few Time Lords enter his TARDIS to create a forbidden dematerialization gun powered by the key.  This Demat gun will erase the target from time itself.  The Sontarans aided by a wormy Time Lord gain access to the TARDIS and chase the Doctor through the labyrinth inside.  Leela's forces join up and destroy all but the commander who is struck by the demat circuit right as he was about to explode the Eye or Harmony.  The demat gun removes the Sontaran commander from time but also destroys itself and wipes the Doctor's memory of the whole incident.  The Doctor goes to leave Gallifrey but Leela has chosen to stay behind with a time lord she had fallen in love with.  K-9 stays with her.  The Doctor leaves and pulls out a box labeled  "K-9 Mark II"

This one is actually very interesting and entertaining.  The mystery of why the Doctor is acting like this goes on for a couple episodes so you aren't really quite sure what's going on and it builds up good tension.  Also getting to see the TARDIS swimming pool and other areas was really cool to see.  There are only two problems when you really sit down and think about it.  First is the fact that the Time Lords of Troughton's The War Games are certainly long gone.  For the Sontarans to cause a legitimate threat to the people who used their minds to erase an entire group of people from history.... yeah these are weak and pointless Time Lords now.  Also Leela's departure is a bit sudden.  She really didn't have much screentime or even chemistry with the character who she seemingly fell in love with.  Yes, Jo Grant left to be with a man she had fallen in love with but they spent plenty of time establishing that connection which made that work.  Here it doesn't.  Despite these two things I personally enjoyed this story; you might want to check it out!

Conclusion

That was Seasons Fourteen and Fifteen of Classic Doctor Who.  It was an interesting collection of really awesome, weird, and unique. For me personally, Leela was the last of the consecutively great companions that the show had to offer.  Don't get me wrong, I like the majority of the companions that will be coming in the future, but precious few of them would fall into the "great" category like everyone since Jamie and Zoe appeared with the Second Doctor.  The best era of the show is officially over with these seasons and honestly wouldn't gain the momentum back for another ten seasons.  We'll still have some really great episodes mixed in though.  Please join me again as we continue to examine all of Doctor Who.

This is Ghost, fading into the darkness
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
You can click here if you wish to see my introduction to Doctor Who
If you want to check out all of my Doctor Who content please click here.

Tuesday, May 17, 2016

Ghost's Kitchen: Denver Omelet Bake

What's Cooking Today?
Denver Omelet Bake

Hello everyone and welcome to another segment of...

Breakfast is always a fun and unique meal.  Lunch and Dinner can so very often be the same types of meals with little or no change between them; if you take any dinner or lunch and ask what meal they are for most people won't be able to tell.  Breakfast is not the same.  For some reason we have designated certain foods to be for early in the morning only unless you decide to have "breakfast for dinner" as eating those foods at that time isn't ever just called "dinner."

Breakfast foods are generally delicious and because of the unique nature of breakfast, I am always intrigued when I come across a new way to make a breakfast food.  I found a version of this recipe online and almost immediately made it twice in the same week because we enjoyed it so much.  If you like fairly simple egg dishes then this might just be the thing for you!

Gather Your Ingredients
  • 8 Eggs
  • 1/2 Cup Half and Half Cream
  • 1 1/2 Cup (6 oz) Shredded Cheddar Cheese
  • 1 Cup Finely Chopped Cooked Ham
    • This is most easily found by buying cubed ham and cutting it into smaller pieces
  • 1/4th Cup Finely Chopped Green Pepper
  • 1/4th Cup Finely Chopped Onion
  • 9x9 Glass Pan
  • Cooking Spray
  • Large Knife for Chopping
  • Chopping Block
  • Measuring Cups
  • Mixing Bowl
  • Wooden spoon
  • Whisk

1. Preheat Oven to 400°F

2. Finely Chop Green Pepper and Onion
It will take around half of a green pepper and 1/4th of an onion in order to make 1/4th of a cup of each.  Chop them, measure out 1/4th cup of each and place them into a bowl or measuring cup to the side.

3. Finely Chop Cooked Ham
Measure out 1 Cup of Ham and chop into small pieces.  Place in same container as the chopped onion and green pepper once finished.

4. Crack Eggs and Add Half and Half
Crack all 8 eggs into a mixing bowl and add the 1/2 cup of Half and Half Cream

5. Whisk Eggs
Whisk the eggs vigorously until the solution is a uniform consistency

6. Measure Cheese
Measure out around a cup and a half of shredded cheddar cheese

7. Mix Onion, Green Pepper, Ham, and Cheese into Mixing Bowl
Make sure the ingredients are thoroughly mixed together

8. Grease Pan

9. Pour Egg Mixture into Pan
Make sure that the mixture remains even and smooth



10. Bake for 30-40 Minutes
This will all depend on your oven.   Mine tends to waver closer to the 40 minute mark.  You will know that it is fully cooked when the top has become golden brown, the whole mixture has risen slightly, and the top layer doesn't easily shake when moved.

11. Cut and Serve

This dish is extremely easy to make.  Yes chopping the ham, onion, and green pepper can be time consuming and slightly irritating but that can probably be quickened by purchasing already diced products if you can find such.  This is perfect to have when guests come over for breakfast or if you plan to have a breakfast meal for dinner.  I hope you enjoy it!


This is Ghost fading into the darkness.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
If you want to see my other food topics and recipes then simply click here!

Friday, May 13, 2016

Whovian Chatter: The Tom Baker Years Seasons Twelve and Thirteen

Ghost here, thanks for joining.

I'm going to be examining Doctor Who... every single episode.  I'm going to take you on a journey through the 50+ years worth of this show, showcasing the good and the bad along the way.  For each episode I'm going to give you a very brief rundown of the plot, how good/bad the story is, and anything interesting about the episode.  Basically I'll just talk about whatever comes to mind for each of them.  These will be a more in-depth overview of the series as a whole so you can see which stories or episodes (if any) you want to check out for yourself.  Today I'm going to be talking about

The Fourth Doctor
Tom Baker
Seasons Twelve and Thirteen

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 
SIDE NOTE
I realized that when I'm talking about the plot of these stories, not only does it generally give everything away but I'm going into too much detail.  I'm going to start just VERY briefly talking about them by just going off the top of my head.  Expect these to start getting a little bit shorter.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 

Season Twelve ran from December 28, 1974 to May 10, 1975.  It contained twenty episodes across five stories.  This season brings in the legend himself, Tom Baker and with him comes the glorious era where we have the most iconic Doctor and the most iconic companion working together.  We also gain a second companion in Harry Sullivan.  Harry was originally created because the producers wanted the fourth Doctor to be another older gentleman like William Hartnell.  They hired Ian Marter for the part before they hired a replacement Doctor.  However, all of the older actors refused the part and they ended up hiring Tom Baker who was much younger, stranger, and fitter.  Harry wasn't really a necessity anymore, and his character suffered for it.  He leaves at the start of next season.  This season also has quite possibly the longest segments of stories that absolutely happen back to back as the TARDIS is missing for the majority of the season.

Season Thirteen ran from August 30, 1975 to March 6, 1976.  It contained twenty six episodes across six stories.  This season was when the new production team really got to stretch their legs and do what they wanted.  As such, this really began the golden era for Tom Baker.  The show became even more popular during this season as the stories were overall excellent.  This high quality and popularity would only last for a few seasons but it's definitely quite a ride.

Season Twelve

Story 75
Robot

The first story of Season Twelve is Robot and it's four episodes long. The Doctor has recently regenerated and his regeneration madness this time has taken form in semi-conscious ramblings and not knowing what clothes are appropriate for the time period.  The Brigadier has Lieutenant Harry Sullivan look after the Doctor, but the Doctor gives him the slip and breaks for the TARDIS. The Brigadier convinces the Doctor to stay as plans for a disintegration gun are stolen.  A group of scientists running a Think Tank have created a robot and intend to use him to steal the nuclear missile codes and hold the world hostage.  The robot, however is having an existential crisis due to his programming and accidentally kills his master then goes semi-berserk.  The Doctor must stop the nuclear codes and save Sarah Jane from an ever growing robot who has grown an attachment to her.

This story is fairly weak.  I would call it the weakest regeneration story, but the Twin Dilemma exists and few things are worse than the Twin Dilemma.  It's not a bad story it's just nothing overly spectacular.  Effectively it's King Kong with a robot instead of a gorilla and it involves nukes.  If that sounds like it'd be interesting then check it out.  When a new Doctor takes over, the production team had generally already laid the ground work for the first couple of stories for him.  As such, this is basically a Pertwee story with a different Doctor.  Unit is involved, it's earth-bound, and the Doctor drives Bessie.  Given what the Tom Baker era eventually became coupled with how good many of his stories were... it just makes this one weird.  This also begins a series of stories that pretty much have to be told back to back as the next story opens with their first trip in the TARDIS together.

Story 76
The Ark in Space

The next story is The Ark in Space and it's four episodes long.  The TARDIS lands on a very old space station where the human race has been in suspended animation until the Earth is inhabitable again.  While there, they find the mummified remains of an insect creature.  One of the medical officers, Vira, is revived from suspended animation who also revives their leader, Noah.  After some investigation, the Doctor informs Vira that they have overslept in suspended animation for several millennia thanks to the insect infestation's sabotage of the control system.  Noah accuses the Doctor of this but becomes infected by the insects and slowly transforming into their swarm leader.  Eventually Noah leads the entire swarm on an assault of the Doctor and crew and end up on a transport ship which the Doctor has set on autopilot.  The last spark of humanity in Noah reappears as he tells Vira goodbye and explodes the transport ship.  The human race can now be revived and returned to earth, but the transmat system isn't functional due to the age of the transmat segment on Earth.  The Doctor, Sarah Jane, and Harry transport down to Earth to fix the receiver.

This is a fairly decent story.  I generally enjoy science fiction stories where a character is going in and out of his humanity and this one does a good job.  Unfortunately some of the effects are kinda laughable especially when the leader is in his in-between stage; he's basically covered in green bubble wrap... but again if I'm going to focus on the special effects then I'm watching the wrong eras of the show.  It's also during this story that the Doctor gives one of his more notable "humanity is amazing" speeches.

Story 77
The Sontaran Experiment

The next story is The Sontaran Experiment and it's two episodes long.  The Doctor, Sarah Jane, and Harry have transported down to Earth.   The Doctor begins fixing the transmat receiver while Sarah Jane and Harry go exploring the uninhabited earth.  The group are eventually separated and Sarah Jane learns that a Sontaran named Styre was sent to Earth to experiment on humans so that the Sontaran fleet know the most effective ways to kill them before they invade.  Styre has been brutally experimenting on the humans he had lured back to Earth and does the same with Sarah Jane.  Eventually the Doctor and Harry rescue Sarah Jane.  Harry and Sarah Jane go to Styre's ship in an attempt to sabotage while the Doctor faces off with Styre one on one.  The Sontaran flees to recharge himself but the sabotage kills him.  With Styre's mission a failure, the Sontaran fleet call off the attack.  The Doctor, Sarah Jane, and Harry transmat back up to the space station... or so they think.

This one is a good one for fans of the new show to watch.  It's about as long as an episode of the new show and it's the classic show at its most dark and unpleasant.  It's an interesting look at the kind of tones and themes that they could be doing.  It's just a shame that the actor playing Styre was sick to the point of death.  He played the original Sontaran and was supposed to use the same mask and costume from The Time Warrior, but due to his massive weight loss thanks to the disease which eventually killed him, the mask was far too loose; it's even kind of loose here.  Also during the shooting, Tom Baker injured himself.  This has the unfortunate consequence of a fight scene between an injured man and a dying man which makes that whole sequence fairly terrible.  Other than the fight scene though, this is a great one.

Story 78
Genesis of the Daleks

The next story is Genesis of the Daleks and it's six episodes long.  While the Doctor, Sarah Jane, and Harry are being transported back to the space station, the Time Lords have other plans and cause them to be transported across space and time to interfere in the creation of the Daleks.  They are given a time ring to activate in order to be taken back to the space station.  While on Skaro, they find a great war between the Thal race and the Kaled race that has utterly destroyed the majority of the planet.  The Doctor is captured by the Kaleds and is present when the Kaled chief scientist, Davros, is there to unveil his new "Dalek" weapon.  However there is concern among the Kaled elite and with the Doctor's help, they decide to halt Davros' mutation experiments.  Davros, however, covertly sends a chemical to the Thals which would destroy the Kaled base which they use almost immediately.  Due to this savage attack, Davros creates more Daleks and removes compassion so that they may exterminate all of the enemy.  With the ensuing chaos, the Doctor has the chance to destroy the Dalek incubator but wonders if he truly has that right.  The choice is avoided when a friendly Kaled informs them that Davros has succumbed to their wishes for him to stop and wants it to be put to a vote.  This turns out to be a ploy as it gave time for his Daleks to return and exterminate those who sided against Davros.  The Doctor sends Harry and Sarah to safety and returns to destroy the incubator but a Dalek accidentally completes the explosion circuit and does it for him.  The Daleks action on their impulses against Davros' will and start production on new Daleks.  Davros goes to hit the self-destruct but is shot by a Dalek.  Though the Daleks were not defeated, they have been hindered for at least a thousand years.  Believing this to be good enough, the Doctor and his companions activate the time ring.

This is the first of the all-time classic Tom Baker stories.  It completely changed the dynamic of the Daleks for both good and bad.  This opened up many more opportunities for stories within the show but it also somewhat reduced the Daleks to soldiers under Davros who just keeps coming back to life for no reason.  It also has two very iconic moments when the Doctor talks with Davros and when the Doctor asks "Have I that right?"  The Kaleds were also heavily influenced by the Nazis which makes it even the more hilarious as Guy Siner is one of the Kaleds.  Siner also played an incompetent Nazi on 'Allo 'Allo! which is a fantastic show I suggest you watch some of.  But because of that show, I can't quite take him as seriously as I should as a Kaled.  Either way, this is a fantastic story that you should check out!


Story 79
Revenge of the Cybermen

The last story of season twelve is Revenge of the Cybermen and it's four episodes long.   The Doctor, Sarah Jane, and Harry arrive back on the space station Nerva but everything isn't quite what they remember.  In fact, they have been sent back to a time a thousand years before they had first arrived on the ship with the TARDIS traveling back in time to meet them thanks to the Time Lords.  They discover that the space station has come under some sort of plague and is orbiting the planet of Voga, a planet of Gold.  As it turns out the crew have not been dying from a plague but rather an attack by the Cybermen who intend to use the space station to destroy Voga.  Voga is the planet of gold and during the great Cyber War, the Cybermen were defeated by Voga because their gold sticks to the Cybermen's breathing apparatus and suffocates them.  It's up to the Doctor to stop the human spy, stop the Cybermen, and save Voga from internal conflict as well as external destruction.

This one is not very good.  This is the first time we have seen the Cybermen since Season Six with Patrick Troughton, and because they were used so terribly here, we won't see them again for seven more seasons.  This story introduced the Cybermen's allergy to gold which is occasionally used well but usually used ridiculously.  Honestly this one's a skip.  I had to look up the wiki article on this story because the only two things I remembered about this story was that Voga was the planet of Gold, and The Doctor shouts "HARRY SULLIVAN IS AN IMBECILE!" at the top of his lungs. 

Season Thirteen

Story 80
Terror of the Zygons

The first story of season thirteen is Terror of the Zygons and it's four episodes long.  Immediately following the Cybermen's defeat at Voga, the Doctor receives a transmission from the Brigadier that they must return to Earth immediately.  A series of oil rigs in Scotland are being destroyed and nobody knows the cause.  When a survivor of the attack washes up on the moor, Harry attempts to help the man but is shot by someone; the survivor being fatally shot.  The Doctor and Sarah return from investigating to see Harry but his bed is empty and the pair are locked in a chamber with the air pumped out.  Thankfully Sergeant Benton finds them in time.  Harry, as it turns out, has been taken to a spaceship deep underwater controlled by creatures called Zygons who can transform their bodies to look like others and have replaced several notable people over the last few years.  Their plan is to conquer Earth using the Loch Ness Monster (which is actually an alien creature) upgraded with cybernetics.  Eventually the Zygons send the Loch Ness Monster to attack the Prime Minister and it's up to the Doctor and UNIT to stop the scheme.  In the end, Harry decides to stay back with UNIT as the Doctor and Sarah Jane leave for the stars.

This is a very good story and only partially because you see the Brigadier wearing a kilt through most of the story!  This story, of course, introduced the Zygons who are yet another one of those iconic alien races that we only see once in the classic show.  These aliens hit a home run in a major way because of their abilities, how alien they look, and their whispering voices.  It's a shame that we won't get to see them again until the 50th anniversary episode in about 38 years.  Also, this ended the stream of Tom Baker stories that definitely happen one right after the other.  You should really check this one out.

Story 81
Planet of Evil

The next story is Planet of Evil and it's four episodes long.  The TARDIS lands on the planet of Zeta Minor where the Doctor and Sarah Jane discover a geological expedition has been wiped out by an unseen killer with only one man left, Professor Sorenson.  At the same time, a military investigation team lands to find out what happened to the scientists.  They blame the Doctor for the deaths but eventually find the killer to be a creature from a universe of antimatter.  The creature was angered when Sorenson took antimatter samples from around the pit that connects the two universes.  The military ship takes off but is dragged back down to towards Zeta Minor due to the antimatter on board the ship.  Sorenson also begins transforming into (*snort*...sorry) the Antiman and begins draining people's life force using antimatter abilities he cannot control.  Eventually the Doctor takes Sorenson and the samples back to Zeta Minor and tosses them into the pit.  The antimatter creature is appeased and gives Sorenson back without his mutation allowing the military and Sorenson to leave the planet.

This story is mostly forgettable with the exception of the way in which the antimatter creature looks, and the utterly ridiculous name that they gave Sorenson when he had mutated.  Having a pit that leads to another universe was a good idea but the fairly ok paint-by-numbers feel to the rest of it just makes this adequate at best.  Watch it if you feel like it.

Story 82
Pyramids of Mars

The next story is Pyramids of Mars and it's four episodes long.  The TARDIS is forced out of its intended flight path when Sarah Jane suddenly sees an apparition in the console room.  The Doctor lands the TARDIS in a priory where there are several Egyptian artifacts.  An Egyptian who has recently been taken over sends a robot disguised as a mummy after the Doctor and Sarah Jane who escape to a nearby hunting lodge.  The man there is an amateur scientist and has created a device that is receiving signals from Mars.  The signal is "Beware Sutekh"  The Doctor explains that Sutekh is the last remaining member of an ancient race known as the Osirans who was banished to an eternal prison on Mars for his cruelty; the Egyptians worshiped them as gods.  Using a time corridor in the priory, Sutekh sends his servant to kill the Egyptian and take over efforts to free Sutekh from his prison by building a rocket.  The Doctor and Sarah Jane halt this by exploding the rocket, but the explosion is contained by Sutekh's telekinetic power.  The Doctor jumps into the time corridor to distract Sutekh causing him to loosen his control and allow the explosion to take place.  Unfortunately, the Doctor is stuck on Mars and Sutekh uses his mental powers to control the Doctor, send him back to the priory and use the TARDIS so his servant and a robot could come to Mars and destroy the artifact keeping him imprisoned.  The Doctor eventually breaks free of the mind control and goes through a series of logic puzzles to reach Sutekh's servant but he is too late.  The servant destroys the Eye of Horace and crumbles to dust.  Thinking quickly, the Doctor returns to the priory and uses the TARDIS power to extent the time corridor that Sutekh was using to reach earth out for 10,000  years meaning Sutekh would die before reaching Earth.

This story is fantastic!  This is an absolute must see.  Not only is it great but it has one of the best voiced villains in the entire series.  I honestly don't know what else to say about it other than the fact that you need to watch it!

Story 83
The Android Invasion

The next story is The Android Invasion and it's four episodes long. The Doctor has agreed to head back to Earth however once the TARDIS lands it appears that the coordinates are off somehow.  The Doctor and Sarah Jane have found themselves in an abandoned village.  Something seems very off as the town is filled with newly minted money, a calendar only has one day repeated, strange men in space suits are patrolling around, and UNIT is being headed by someone other than the Brigadier.  It turns out that this is a testing facility for an alien race known as the Kraals to test their android technology.  They intend to use these androids to conquer Earth little by little.  During the confusion, Sarah Jane gets kidnapped and duplicated as an android.  It's up to the Doctor to realize his companion has been swapped and stop the Kraals from initiating their plan.

This is a fairly standard story with middle-of-the-road quality.  There's a good mystery and some inventive aliens.  There just isn't much that stands out.  It's not a bad story by any means it just has the unfortunate luck to be position between two absolutely brilliant classic stories.  If android duplicates interest you then give this one a try.

Story 84
The Brain of Morbius

The next story is The Brain of Morbius and it's four episodes long.  The TARDIS lands on the planet of Karn and the Doctor believes it is the Time Lords who have sent him.  The Doctor and Sarah Jane find a castle and meet it's owner, a surgeon named Solon.  Solon is secretly trying to build a new body for the evil Time Lord Morbius who was executed and thought dead for many years.  Meanwhile, the Sisterhood of Karn, a group of ladies who guard the "sacred flame" which gives eternal life are having trouble as the fire is going out and they fear the Time Lords have sent the Doctor to steal the elixer of life.  Solon decides to use the Doctor's head as the final piece of Morbius' new body and drugs him.  However, the sisterhood teleport the Doctor to their headquarters and set to burn him at the stake.  Solon speaks with Morbius' brain which is being kept in a jar and decides to use Sarah Jane's head instead.  Eventually the Sisterhood and the Doctor reach an understanding as he restores the flame of life by removing the soot blocking the hole.  When Sarah Jane is rescued by the Doctor, Solon decides to use a mechanical head and places Morbius' mind inside the body.  Morbius is alive once again and out of control.  The Doctor challenges Morbius to a mind battle in an attempt to save the galaxy from the most vile Time Lord in existence.

Yet another absolutely fantastic story and a must-see!  The most important thing to come from this story is the Sisterhood of Karn; the group of immortal women who were good friends with the Time Lords for many years.  Although this was their only appearance in the classic show, the new show was wise to remember their existence and brought them back into public consciousness around the 50th anniversary episode as well as Season 9.  One of the more "controversial" parts of this episode is he Mind Battle.  Both the Doctor and Morbius are strapped to a machine and the Doctor's past regenerations are seen.  Unfortunately, the pictures keep going after William Hartnell.  It was originally intended that the First Doctor was not his first life.  However, next season's "The Deadly Assassin" happened in which it was mentioned the number of regenerations a Time Lord has per cycle so everything seen here was tossed out of continuity.  The Doctor Who Community, however, came up with the theory that these faces were actually Morbius' previous versions.  Either way, give this one a watch!

Story 85
The Seeds of Doom

The last story of Season Thirteen is The Seeds of Doom and it's six episodes long.  When a strange plant pod is discovered in Antarctica, the Doctor recognizes the photo as alien and heads off to Antarctica with Sarah Jane.  The pod opens and attaches itself to a scientist, slowly turning him into a plant-like alien called a Krynoid.  Meanwhile, word of this rare pod has reached an insane plant enthusiast, Harrison Chase.  Chase sends two men to Antarctica to steal the pod for his collection.  The Doctor, Sarah Jane, and the two henchmen arrive to find that the Krynoid man has killed everyone else in the base.  The Doctor remembers that Krynoid pods come in pairs and goes after the Krynoid.  The henchmen steal the second pod and place a bomb in the base which explodes, killing the Krynoid.  In England, Chase is examining the pod when it too opens and attaches itself to one of the henchmen.  Just like in Antarctica, the man starts turning into a Krynoid.  Chase has decided to work with the Krynoid so that plants can rule the world.  The Doctor and Sarah Jane contact UNIT and enter Chase's mansion to stop the Krynoid, however the alien has grown too large and is about to germinate all of England.  Can UNIT strike it down before it's too late?  Well yeah, of course they do!

This is yet another good episode that you may want to check out.  The early Tom Baker stories are by far some of the best stories in the classic show.  We have about two more seasons worth of really great stuff until the quality takes a nosedive that won't recover until the 7th Doctor.  One of the most notable things about this story is the brutality in a couple of the deaths.  While many deaths have been uncomfortable in the history of the show, this story has two people being pulled into a compost shredder!  Geez!

Conclusion

That was Seasons Twelve and Thirteen of Classic Doctor Who.  If I haven't made it abundantly clear yet, many of the stories from Tom Baker's first two seasons are absolute classics and must-sees.  The writers were on a roll and were constantly producing high quality work.  This high quality coupled with Tom Baker's own eccentricity that he brought to the role (most of it purely because that was his own personality) made this era one of the best out of both the classic and new shows combined.  There's a reason that Tom Baker is still the most iconic Doctor and most likely always will be.  Just check out these episodes and you'll see why.  Thankfully we have two more seasons of awesomeness before the quality starts to drop a bit, then a bit more, then a LOT more.  Please join me again as we continue to examine all of Doctor Who.


This is Ghost, fading into the darkness
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -  
You can click here if you wish to see my introduction to Doctor Who
If you want to check out all of my Doctor Who content please click here.

Tuesday, May 10, 2016

Ghost in the Case: God's Not Dead

"I just keep thinking of that C. S. Lewis line, 'Only a real risk can test the reality of a belief'."

Ghost here!  Thanks for joining me today for yet another

Did you ever have an idea pop up that you decide to act upon only to later realize it's probably not that great of an idea but you're going to do it anyway?  Well that's kinda how I came about reviewing today's film.  How did this come about?  Well let's start at the beginning.

In 2014, the film God's Not Dead was released in theaters.  The trailers for the film promised us an intellectual debate between an atheist philosophy professor and a christian student in his class in an attempt to prove the existence of God.  To the surprise of many, it became a smash hit grossing in 62 million dollars when the film only took 2 million to make.  This was so successful that this year they released a sequel to the film (though I think they missed the golden opportunity to call it God's Still Not Dead rather than God's Not Dead 2.) Pastors and Christian groups across the nation were encouraging people to see this film; praising it as a way to share the Christian faith and strengthen your own.  At the same time, film critics were absolutely trashing the film left and right due to numerous faults they could see with the film.  Eventually, when the film came out on DVD, a local church decided to play it as an outreach and I went to view the film.

Ever since watching the film, I've had some desire to cover it on the blog.  This is especially true because of the extreme differences in opinion on this film.  I am a Christian; I am a believer in Jesus Christ.  However, even though I'm purely amateur at it I like to think I do a decent job pointing out the positives and negatives of a movie and as such can judge the quality of a movie fairly well.  Most people I have seen review this film are critics who may or may not have the same belief system as the filmmakers, or people such as Pastors who don't regularly offer opinions on film.  Since I fit into both categories, I feel as though I should tackle this one.   Is it as brilliant as many in the Christian community believe?  Is it as bad as most professional critics believe?  Let's find out.

The Plot

When freshman college student Josh Wheaton (yes feel free to chuckle) registers for classes, his registrar notices his cross necklace and comments that he may want to change his Philosophy class.  Josh decides not to heed his warning and attends Professor Jeffrey Radisson's Introduction to Philosophy class.   Prof. Radisson is an atheist who doesn't want to use his class time to argue whether or not there is a God.  He demands that his class write "God is dead" on a piece of paper and sign it.  Josh cannot bring himself to do this as he believes God is real.  Radisson informs him that if he does not sign the paper he will be forced to debate the topic of God's existence in the last twenty minutes of the next three classes and if he fails to do so he will fail that portion of the class and lose 30% of his grade.  If he signs the paper even in the next class Radisson will ignore the entire thing and move on.  Josh seeks the advice of a local pastor and begins his research for his debate.

Despite his girlfriend and parent's telling him not to, Josh goes to Philosophy and presents his case.  His first topic is the origin of the universe and how the comments about the Big Bang sound very much like what would happen if God said "let there be light."  Radisson counters his argument with a comment by Steven Hawking that basically stated that because there is gravity the universe could have created itself.  Josh has no counter argument at that time and the session ends.  As a result of his decision, Josh's girlfriend breaks up with him; however a student from China, Martin, has become more curious about God because of Josh's standpoint.  At this point it's prudent to also mention the other side plots that are intertwining through this story.  Radisson's Christian girlfriend has a mother with dementia.  Her brother, who has no redeeming qualities, is dating a liberal blogger who has just been diagnosed with cancer; he dumps her because of this.  Also the pastor Josh seeks advice for is constantly trying to get to Disney World with a missionary friend but can't because of car trouble.  Lastly there is a Muslim girl hiding her faith from her father who overhears Josh and his girlfriend argue.

Josh's second session brings about an counter to Radisson's comment about Hawking, stating that it is actual circular reasoning.  He then proceeds to point out another scientist's counters to Hawking's theory.  However, Radisson has more counters to his arguments.  It is at this point when both Josh and Radisson are alone that Radisson reveals he once was a believer but stopped believing in God when his mother passed away.  Josh leaves to prepare for his final session.  It is during this time that Martin is having conversations with his father in China about God, Radisson's girlfriend breaks up with him, the blogger comes to terms with her illness, and the Muslim girl's father finds out about her faith, beats her slightly, and disowns her.  The pastor and missionary still can't get their car running, but because of these delays, the pastor is able to help Radisson's girlfriend and the Muslim girl.

It's the final day of Josh's sessions and Radisson has decided to shake things up a bit by making it a full on debate between the two of them.  Each begin parrying the others comments.  Ultimately, Josh breaks Radisson's composure by asking why he hates God.  Eventually Radisson snaps and shouts that he hates God because he took everything from him; that Radisson has nothing but hatred for God.  Josh simply asks how Radisson could hate someone that doesn't exist.  The students, with Martin in the lead, side with Josh.  Josh decides to take Martin with him to the concert for the Christian Artists, Newsboys after the class.  Almost everyone in the movie has tickets to see them, and the blogger using her press pass goes to meet with Newsboys.  There, they lead her in the salvation prayer before their concert.

At this time the pastor and missionary have finally been able to get their car to function but are stuck by the crowds going to the concert.  Radisson, having thought over his class that day, reads a note from his late mother and decides to reconcile with his girlfriend.  Figuring she was at the Newsboys concert he rushes over.  Unfortunately along his say, the professor is fatally struck by a hit-and-run driver.  The Pastor is able to get out and lead Radisson in the salvation prayer just before he passes.  The film ends with the Newsboys' song "God's Not Dead."

What's Cinematically Good About It?

I enjoyed Kevin Sorbo's performance.  Although I think his character could have been written/created a little bit better (I'll get to that in a later segment), Sorbo did a fantastic job with the type of character he was given.  Many of the other actors gave good performances, but the seasoned skills that Sorbo has shown through.  You could just tell he was enjoying his time on screen.  Even when he was being a horrible person, you were always watching him when he was on screen.  Possibly my favorite moment of his is when another student in the class asks what a theist is.  The reaction he produced clearly stated that he just realized his class was full of morons.  It was fantastic.  He was truly the standout performer in this film.

The cinematography of this film was really quite good.  Due to budgetary constraints of these types of films, many of them have a very direct-to-video feel to them.  Some of them even seem like it was just a student film using whatever equipment they could find.  This one was different.  With only a 2 million budget, it's not the type of cinematic quality of something like The Force Awakens, or Captain America.  That being said it's definitely leagues in the right step for quality.  Nothing about the way this film is presented seems cheap.  The scene where Radisson is struck by the car could have easily been done off screen but they went the extra mile to show the impact from inside the car and show a shot of Radisson airborne as you can see here.  It's a well made product.

What's Cinematically Bad About It?

The single biggest issue about this film is that it ultimately became an ensemble movie; this was not what we were promised.  The trailers and comments about the movie pointed to this big debate between student and teacher.  While we did get parts of that, we also got five or six other subplots weaving in and out of the story.  Many of these subplots have very little to do with the actual main story.  I'm specifically talking about the blogger and the Muslim girl.  Their involvement in the main story is that the blogger is the now ex-girlfriend of the brother of the girlfriend of the professor.  The Muslim girl just works in the cafeteria and overhears Josh and his girlfriend arguing.  That's why I just sort of tossed the subplots in the plot section the way in which I did... they don't really connect to the overall story that this film was trying to tell originally.  Trying to tie too many subplots together made the film very unfocused.  When you're trying to do something like showcase a debate between an atheist and a Christian on the existence of God you NEED that focus rather than distracting everyone with other stuff going on.

The editing has made the ensemble nature of the film even worse.  I'm not entirely certain what people were thinking when it came down to editing this film.  If you want to do an ensemble piece, that's fine.  However, you should know when and where to swap over to other people.  God's Not Dead, however has decided to just randomly toss in other people's actions in the MIDDLE OF A SCENE.  I may have mentioned the entire debate as one segment during my plot explanation, but that's not how the film does it.  Professor Radisson's first class where he expects the students to write "God is dead" is interrupted by the arrival of the missionary, then it goes right back to the same scene and moment with Radisson as when we left off.  Both of Josh's first two debate sessions are paused mid-way through to show what's happening with other characters then it comes right back to the debate.  Don't do that!  Finish the scene then go to someone else.  It only makes the film more unfocused when you slide to something else mid-scene then come back.

Is the Christian Message Good?

Speaking as a Christian, the message was a good one.  Believe in Jesus Christ.  Take a stand for Jesus against whatever odds.  God is in control of everything and even bad situations have a purpose.  You can find comfort in Jesus during your time of need.  You must simply believe in Jesus Christ as your savior, accept Him into your heart and believe.  God Is Not Dead.  All of the messages being presented within this film are wonderful and may even be able to bring non-believers over to Christianity.

However, is the message effective?  No... not really.  When you are trying to get a point or a message across to people you need to have a focus and the cinematic "sins" of this film make it so unfocused that this message, while a good message, can easily be lost on people.

How Could the Message be More Effective?
I would like to preface this that I am coming to this portion under the realization that this film was a commercial success.  It was so successful that they made a sequel and it included characters from this first film.  There was no way of knowing during development that there would be a sequel for characters to return in and I can't necessarily fault them on that.  That being said, I believe the changes I suggest would have made this a far better film/set of films.

The first thing to do, would be to make the non-Christians more rounded and not complete jerks like basically all of them were written as.  We have the brother of the girlfriend who has absolutely no redeeming qualities in the film whatsoever.  He gets told that his girlfriend has cancer and he breaks up with her on the spot with no concern for her life or health.  The Muslim father we barely even get to see that much.  All we see of him is his belief that nobody worships God "the way He deserves,"  then next time we see him he's beating the crap out of his daughter and physically throwing her out of his front door.  However, it was Radisson's random anger that really took me by surprise.  Before the scene pictured here, he was just an atheist who was sure he was right and was amused by Josh's determination.  Then this scene happened where he grab hold of Josh, screams about not being ridiculed in his class (which didn't happen) and vows to personally destroy his future career if he continues with his discussions.  1. You would be SO FIRED if this were the real world.  2. You were the one who started this whole thing to begin with.  I realize that there are some people out there who may exhibit these qualities but this kind of stuff is not the norm.  Just make these characters more relatable and a bit more likeable.  Why is this such a big deal?  A common criticism by non-believers is that the non-believers in the film are grossly demonized and it put them off; I'd be lying if I said I couldn't see that so some extent.

While we're on the topic of Professor Radisson, wouldn't it have been more powerful for Radisson to have lived?  Yes, films love a good death scene/sequence and it did show that even someone at the end of their life can accept Jesus.  That being said I think it would have been more powerful for Radisson to have found his girlfriend and had the Newsboys lead him in the salvation prayer rather than the blogger.  He could then return to his classroom with a new outlook and be a Christian influence in the Philosophy department where atheism is most prominent.  As-is, in the world they created, his legacy would be a bitter angry atheist and only God, the preacher, the missionary, and himself would know the truth about his final decision. 

Lastly, the greatest thing they could have done was focus the film.  This could be done by trimming out some of the subplots and making them sequels or included in sequels.

First Film
This would be the story of Josh and Professor Radisson.  The main plotline would be intact as well as the Chinese Student, Martin, and Professor Radisson's girlfriend as these two are the only ones with real ties to the main players in this story.  Pastor Dave would be there to help point Josh and Radisson's girlfriend in the right direction and would be a recurring character throughout all of the other films.  The film would focus on the debate and keep those segments completely intact without jumping to other scenes in the middle.  It would be more of a true debate and at the end Radisson would go to the Newsboys concert, accept Jesus and return to campus.  The girlfriend's brother and mother would be removed from the series entirely.  This movie's basic theme would be standing up for Jesus and finding redemption through Him.

Second Film
This would be the story of God's Not Dead 2 (which I haven't seen.)  This would follow the story of the teacher being put on trial for expressing her belief in God.  This movie would have the blogger's side story as she would be following the case thus giving her purpose in the entire story.  The main plot of that movie would be intact and would give the blogger something more meaningful and give her more time to grieve over her condition and find peace at the end.  Professor Radisson could show up in support of the teacher and Pastor Dave would be there to help out everyone again.  This movie's theme would be how to share your belief in a tough situation and finding peace in the midst of turmoil.

Third Film
This would be the story of the Muslim girl given a LOT more thought and effort.  It would start from the very beginning of the girl's belief in Jesus and take us on the journey of how she believed in a Muslim home.  It would possibly still have her being kicked out but without the domestic abuse.  Pastor Dave would show up to assist her through her journey, help get her back on her feet, and provide her with the ways to share Christianity to those of Muslim faith.  Perhaps her younger brother would be slightly receptive or her family would still allow her to visit thus allowing her to be a Christian influence in that area.  This movie's theme would be choosing to follow Jesus no matter the cost and show how to be an influence despite the religious differences.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I honestly feel if the filmmakers would have done a more focused series of films the Christian messages they were trying to bring out would have been must more poignant and effective.

Conclusion

Despite it's best intentions, I found this movie to be really lacking in focus.  As I said previously, the trailers and box promise a debate on the existence of God.  While we do get that, we end up with an onslaught of subplots that have very little or nothing to do with the overall plot... sometimes interrupting the plot itself.  If i were to file this under any sort of category I'd put this in the "not great" category.  It's got some enjoyable performances and it's competently shot; I actually enjoyed it more the second time I watched it because I knew what to expect.  The editing and meandering of the plot just sort of killed the momentum for me the first time. 

If you are a believing Christian then you will most likely enjoy this on some level.  The acting is pretty good, especially Kevin Sorbo.  The messages being told throughout are good and it will reinforce your belief.  If you are not a Christian but are interested in Christianity.... you may find something here.  I'm not going to massively dump on anything that has the potential to bring someone to Christianity.  That being said, I feel as though The Jesus Film might do a better job since this one is lacking in focus.  If you are not a Christian and have no intentions of becoming one then... well I couldn't tell you to not watch this film per say.  You never know what might be that one thing that nudges someone in the direction of Christianity, but you probably won't find that much here.

God's Not Dead is rated PG and is available on DVD from Pure Flix.  It is also available for streaming on Hulu.

This is Ghost, fading into the darkness.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
If you want to see my other Movie and Television reviews/recommendations then simply click here!